I think that the Allies went completely overboard with the Treaty of Versailles. It is certainly understandable that they, and especially France, are angry at Germany and want revenge, but they took it too far.
The part about limiting Germany's army and navy, and not letting them have any heavy artillery is pretty reasonable. The Allies want to make sure that Germany cannot attack again in the future with such force as they did in WWI. Although, to Germany that must have been pretty degrading. It is like they are a child who is being punished; they had this toy (their military) and they misused it, and now it is being taken away from them.
Also, taking away a lot of Germany's land is somewhat understandable. If it is land that they took during the war, then yes, they should give it back. It only makes sense. Not allowing Germany to have any colonies is a bit harsh though. I cannot see any legitimate reason France or Britain would not want Germany to have any colonies, other than the fact that they want the land for themselves. And in that case, it is completely unfair to the citizens of those lands to have their country's ownership negotiated over without them ever having a say in the issue. That was completely unfair of France and Britain, not so much as from Germany's point of view, but from the view of the colonies.
One section of the treaty that is unfair to Germany is the "Guilt Clause". I think that it is mostly Germany's fault that the war was as horrible as it was, because they were the strongest force of the Central Powers and did the most damage, but they are certainly not to be blamed for the entire war. First of all, this whole thing started with Serbia and Austria-Hungry. Austria-Hungry was first to declare war on Serbia. Sure, Germany gave AH the "blank check", saying they would support AH unconditionally, but that does not mean that Germany started the war. Austria-Hungry did. And therefore, Germany should not be blamed for the entire war.
The most ridiculous portion of the Treaty of Versailles is definitely the financial part. The Allies set an impossible cost on the war that Germany was expected to pay. There is no way that any country could have been able to pay that. And even if they could, they would be so utterly broke afterwords that the country would collapse. I know Germany had a lot of problems after the war, but I am surprised that they even survived at all. That was probably the intention of this part of the treaty though, to destroy Germany.
I don't understand how this treaty was actually approved. France and the other Allies definitely wanted their revenge, but how did they get away with it? Shouldn't someone have stood up for Germany? I know Woodrow Wilson didn't think Germany should be punished like that, but why did no other country realize how unfair the treaty was and try to change it? Or did they and then the Allies stopped them? It just seems crazy to me that this happened and no one stopped to think of how unfair the treaty was or how much damage it would actually do to Germany and its citizens. Because that is who the treaty was hurting the most, Germany's citizens. Not its leaders or war generals like it should have, because that is who the revenge should have been aimed at.
Saturday, October 23, 2010
Tuesday, September 21, 2010
My Propaganda
Okay so I tried to work this toondoo thing. I'm really bad at technology though. It doesn't look like how I wanted it to, but I think everyone gets the idea of it, or of what I was trying to get it to look like, right?
Friday, August 27, 2010
What Creates a World War?
Countries are so diverse. They have different holidays and cultures, their geography differs, the language they speak is defferent. They also govern their countries differently and have different resources naturally available to them in their land. Especially those last two reasons are why countries don't get along sometimes. And when they REALLY don't get along, war can start.
When war starts between two countries, their allies often will help finance the war, provide them with weapons, or even send troops to help fight. When many countries start doing this, it becomes a world war. In order to create a world war, there needs to be at least two sides involving at least two countries that then get their allies involved in the war.
I think that another world war today is very possible. The U.S. doesn't agree with how other countries are run, for example, North Korea, and if North Korea did something we didn't agree with, we could start war with them. Depending on what other countries want, they could decide to join sides and help fight. North Korea was just an example though. We are also very dependent on other countries for resources such as oil. When coutries are so dependent and desparate for such resources, they may be greedy and drastic with their actions. If our import of resources was for some reason denied or anything got in the way of our agreement with other countries on that, we could intervene and start war. Once again though, depending on the opinions of other countries, it might not turn into a world war. It depends on the web of alliances and how many countries choose to get involved. Another world war in the future is very possible though.
When war starts between two countries, their allies often will help finance the war, provide them with weapons, or even send troops to help fight. When many countries start doing this, it becomes a world war. In order to create a world war, there needs to be at least two sides involving at least two countries that then get their allies involved in the war.
I think that another world war today is very possible. The U.S. doesn't agree with how other countries are run, for example, North Korea, and if North Korea did something we didn't agree with, we could start war with them. Depending on what other countries want, they could decide to join sides and help fight. North Korea was just an example though. We are also very dependent on other countries for resources such as oil. When coutries are so dependent and desparate for such resources, they may be greedy and drastic with their actions. If our import of resources was for some reason denied or anything got in the way of our agreement with other countries on that, we could intervene and start war. Once again though, depending on the opinions of other countries, it might not turn into a world war. It depends on the web of alliances and how many countries choose to get involved. Another world war in the future is very possible though.
Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
